Crash Course: What Happens If Your Car Is Totaled?

Tony Mers • May 11, 2019
paint shop

Fender benders happen. No big deal. Usually. But, given the technology that goes into even the smallest parts of your car, and how damage to those technologies can result in system-wide problems, you might be surprised at how relatively easy it is to total your car. Every year, there are about six million car accidents in the U.S. 72% of those accidents result in property damage, some of which may be sufficient to total your car.


Should this happen to you, making this unfortunate experience less painful is possible and depends largely on wise preparation. It’s common for drivers to believe that a car must be a mangled mess to be totaled, but this is not necessarily the case, so it’s important to get familiar with the facts and be as prepared as possible.


How Insurance Companies Determine That Your Car Is Totaled.


Insurance companies make this determination based on the cost of repairs to be made versus the value of the car. If a car body shop or paint shopwill need to perform car repairs after an accident, such as body work and cosmetic repairs, that cost more than the car’s overall value, the car is considered totaled. After a serious car accident, getting a car fixed can exceed the car’s resale amount, rendering the car not worth the insurance company’s repair spend. An appraiser will evaluate the damage to make this determination. Older cars are more likely to be categorized as totaled as they tend to have low resale value. In some states, laws dictate when a car is totaled. Ask your collision and paint shop about any such regulations in your area.


Find Your Vehicle’s Title. Your insurance company will want to know whether you still owe a balance on your car’s purchase price. If your vehicle is paid off, your insurer will ask you to produce your car’s title and car loan payoff documentation as proof that you don’t owe anything on the vehicle.


Identify a Body Shop You Can Trust. Your collision and paint shop will be who can tell you how much repairing your car would cost. Given how much is riding on this calculation, going with a shop you have experience with or are referred to by friends or family lets you rest easy that you are getting accurate information to pass along to your insurance company. Your insurance company will often recommend certain body shops for you to visit. However, remember that the choice of body shop is ultimately yours. Legally, you are free to forego use of the body shop your insurance company prefers and go with your own choice.


Once you’ve got all the information and documentation you need, your body shop and insurance company will work with you to determine the fate of your totaled car. A silver lining: you may find yourself in a new ride sooner than you thought!


A black car with illuminated rear lights parked indoors beside another black car on a wet shop floor
October 13, 2026
Car bumper damage can result from collisions, parking accidents, and harsh weather. Learn the common causes and when you need professional repairs.
A person wearing a respirator spraying paint on a masked vehicle inside a work bay with tools mounte
By River North Collision Repair • September 24, 2026
Can a body shop match original factory paint? Find out how professional paint matching and blending help create a smooth, consistent vehicle finish.
A woman wearing sunglasses and a patterned scarf leaning against a black car inside an auto service
By River North Collision Repair • September 17, 2026
Spot common signs of pothole damage, from tire problems to dents, vibrations, and uneven wear. Know when your car may need professional repairs.
A black SUV with open doors parked inside an auto service bay with hoses, bins, other cars, and over
September 15, 2026
Looking to repair or replace your car? Before deciding which option works for you, consider repair costs, your vehicle's value, the damage, and safety.
A person wearing gloves using a polisher on a gray car panel with yellow tape along the window edges
September 3, 2026
Car paint damage from accidents, vandalism, or weather may qualify for insurance coverage. Learn what factors can affect your claim and repair costs.
August 27, 2026
Foggy headlights can reduce visibility and affect your vehicle’s appearance. Find out what causes cloudy lenses and how professional repair can restore clarity.
Auto Body Shop vs Dealership: Cost, Quality, and Time
August 25, 2026
Compare an auto body shop vs. a dealership for cost, repair quality, and turnaround time to choose the right collision repair option for your vehicle.
A woman holding up a key fob in front of a black car that is parked indoors, with the front grille
August 24, 2026
Protect your car from door dings with nine practical parking tips that help prevent dents, preserve your vehicle's appearance, and reduce repair costs.
A man wiping the front of a black car with an orange cloth inside an automotive service area with eq
By River North Collision Repair • August 10, 2026
Restore oxidized car paint before fading and surface damage worsen. Find the common causes and restoration options that protect your vehicle's finish.